Shop Custom & Personalized Fashion Jewelry

Give a thoughtful, unforgettable gift when you shop personalized jewelry from KAY. Choose from beautiful birthstones, metals, name pendants, bracelets, and more to create a unique personalized piece.

1509 Results

Sort By:

Heart-Shaped Amethyst & White Lab-Created Sapphire Angel Wings & Cross Necklace Sterling Silver 18"
Personalized ORDER BY 4/30/2025

$129.99

Nataila Fashion Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$189.99

Baguette Birthstone Family & Mother's Ring (2-4 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$116.48

Birthstone Couple's Initial Necklace (1 Stone and 2 Initials)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$111.06

Heart Birthstone Couple's Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$109.06

Couple's Engravable Diamond Accent Heart Bracelet 14K Yellow Gold 7.5"
Personalized ORDER BY 4/29/2025

$999.99

Birthstone Claddagh 7" Bangle Bracelet (1 Stone)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$152.71

White Lab-Created Sapphire Zodiac Sagittarius Bolo Bracelet 10K Yellow Gold 9.5"
Personalized ORDER BY 4/30/2025

$649.99

Legacy Men's Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$399.99

Family Birth Flower & Name Heart Cutout Disc Necklace 10K White Gold 18"
Personalized ORDER BY 4/29/2025

$799.99

Stackable 2mm Birthstone Eternity Ring (1 Stone)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$88.60

Medalist Men's Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$499.99

Men's Lab-Created Emerald "Mr." Cuban Chain Necklace Sterling Silver & 10K Yellow Gold 20"
Personalized ORDER BY 4/30/2025

$249.99

Regal Prestige Ladies' Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$729.99

Prestige Petite Ladies' Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$849.99

Summer Breeze Ladies' Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$479.99

Heartstrings Ladies' Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$299.99

Elite Men's Class Ring
Personalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

$779.99

Family & Mother's Birthstone Heart Necklace (2-4 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$146.10

Mother's Family Birthstone Swirl Ring (1-4 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$110.00

Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Drop Necklace (1-3 Stones and 2-3 Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$104.47

Engravable Wedding Band (2 Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$45.79

Mother's Family Birthstone Ring (2-5 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$85.69

Mother's Family Birthstone Ring (1-3 Stones and 2-3 Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$122.29

Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Swirl Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$114.63

Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Infinity Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$120.37

Round Birthstone Family & Mother's Criss Cross Ring (1-4 Stones and 2-4 Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$100.69

Birthstone Family & Mother's Bracelet (1-6 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$139.49

Birthstone Family & Mother's Heart Vertical Bar Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$122.45

1/10 ct tw Diamond and Birthstone Round Disc Charm Necklace (1 Stone and Initial)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$173.58

Script Name Necklace (1 Name)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$94.57

Mother's Family Birthstone Swirl Ring (2-4 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$131.55

Family & Mother's Birthstone Crossover Ring (1-3 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$124.24

Engravable Men's Ring (2 Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$45.76

Mother's Family Birthstone & Diamond Heart Necklace (1-7 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$100.50

Mother's Family Birthstone Asymmetric Contoured Ring (1-5 Stones and 2-5 Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$107.66

Mother's Family Heart-Shaped Birthstone Necklace (2-7 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$129.66

Heart Birthstone Family & Mother's Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$110.42

Oval-Cut Family & Mother's Birthstone Ring (1-4 Stones)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$89.79

Diamond Block Initial Necklace (1 Initial)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$97.62

Family & Mother's Nameplate Necklace (3 Names)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$129.48

Engravable Etched Wedding Band (1 Line)
Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

$66.11

Showing 42 of 1509

Filter By

Get It Fast

Get It By Mother's Day

Best Sellers

Price

Jewelry Type

Gender

Style

Metal Color

Metal Type

Stone Type

Stone Shape

Stone Color

Collections

Carat Range

Customer Rating

Heart-Shaped Amethyst & White Lab-Created Sapphire Angel Wings & Cross Necklace Sterling Silver 18"Personalized ORDER BY 4/30/2025

Nataila Fashion Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Baguette Birthstone Family & Mother's Ring (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Birthstone Couple's Initial Necklace (1 Stone and 2 Initials)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Heart Birthstone Couple's Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Couple's Engravable Diamond Accent Heart Bracelet 14K Yellow Gold 7.5"Personalized ORDER BY 4/29/2025

Birthstone Claddagh 7" Bangle Bracelet (1 Stone)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

White Lab-Created Sapphire Zodiac Sagittarius Bolo Bracelet 10K Yellow Gold 9.5"Personalized ORDER BY 4/30/2025

Legacy Men's Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Family Birth Flower & Name Heart Cutout Disc Necklace 10K White Gold 18"Personalized ORDER BY 4/29/2025

Stackable 2mm Birthstone Eternity Ring (1 Stone)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Medalist Men's Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Men's Lab-Created Emerald "Mr." Cuban Chain Necklace Sterling Silver & 10K Yellow Gold 20"Personalized ORDER BY 4/30/2025

Regal Prestige Ladies' Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Prestige Petite Ladies' Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Summer Breeze Ladies' Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Heartstrings Ladies' Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Elite Men's Class RingPersonalized ORDER BY 3/20/2025

Family & Mother's Birthstone Heart Necklace (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Birthstone Swirl Ring (1-4 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Drop Necklace (1-3 Stones and 2-3 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Engravable Wedding Band (2 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Birthstone Ring (2-5 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Birthstone Ring (1-3 Stones and 2-3 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Swirl Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Infinity Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Round Birthstone Family & Mother's Criss Cross Ring (1-4 Stones and 2-4 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Birthstone Family & Mother's Bracelet (1-6 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Birthstone Family & Mother's Heart Vertical Bar Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

1/10 ct tw Diamond and Birthstone Round Disc Charm Necklace (1 Stone and Initial)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Script Name Necklace (1 Name)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Birthstone Swirl Ring (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Family & Mother's Birthstone Crossover Ring (1-3 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Engravable Men's Ring (2 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Birthstone & Diamond Heart Necklace (1-7 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Birthstone Asymmetric Contoured Ring (1-5 Stones and 2-5 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Mother's Family Heart-Shaped Birthstone Necklace (2-7 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Heart Birthstone Family & Mother's Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Oval-Cut Family & Mother's Birthstone Ring (1-4 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Diamond Block Initial Necklace (1 Initial)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Family & Mother's Nameplate Necklace (3 Names)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025

Engravable Etched Wedding Band (1 Line)Personalized ORDER BY 4/24/2025