Impress your loved ones within your budget without sacrificing quality. At Kay you can get jewelry under $500 for any occasion. Browse our selection of affordable jewelry gifts by occasion or recipient. Say yes to Kay's collection of jewelry and never miss a chance to impress your loved ones.
97 Results items returned.
97 Results items returned.
- Price Low to High
- Price High to Low
- Newest Arrivals
- Most popular
Filter By
97 Results items returned.
- Price Low to High
- Price High to Low
- Newest Arrivals
- Most popular
Unstoppable Love Necklace 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver 19"Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$149.99
Was $249.99
Men's Lord's Prayer Cross Necklace Stainless SteelSale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$49.99
Was $84.99
Hallmark Diamonds Heart Necklace 1/20 ct tw Sterling Silver 18"Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$69.99
Was $129.99
Men's Cross Necklace Lord's Prayer Stainless SteelSale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$59.99
Was $99.99
Disney Treasures Winnie the Pooh "Eeyore" Diamond Necklace 1/15 ct tw Sterling Silver & 10K Rose Gold 19"Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$199.99
Was $349.99
Hallmark Diamonds Heart Bolo Bracelet 1/10 ct tw Sterling SilverSale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$149.99
Was $249.99
Amethyst Heart Necklace Diamond Accents Sterling SilverSale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$79.99
Was $139.99
Star Wars Ahsoka Tano Necklace 1/10 ct tw Diamonds Sterling Silver & 10K Yellow Gold 18"Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$229.99
Was $449.99
Encircled by Love Diamond Necklace 1/4 ct tw Round-cut Sterling Silver 18"Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$249.99
Was $399.99
Hallmark Diamonds Heart Necklace 1/15 ct tw Sterling Silver 18"GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$125.99
Was $179.99
Now + Forever 8mm Wedding Band Tungsten Carbide Black PVDGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$224.99
Was $299.99
8mm Natural Sapphire Wedding Band Black Tungsten CarbideGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$337.49
Was $449.99
Now + Forever Men's Wedding Band Black/Blue Ion-Plated Stainless Steel 8mmGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$112.49
Was $149.99
Now + Forever 6mm Brushed Wedding Band Yellow Tungsten CarbideGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$164.99
Was $219.99
Family & Mother's Birthstone Heart Necklace (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Starting at
$135.23
Now + Forever Men's Wedding Band Titanium 8mmOnline Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$74.99
Was $99.99
Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Infinity Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Starting at
$116.74
Now + Forever Men's Cross Wedding Band Stainless Steel/Yellow Ion-Plating 8mmGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$74.99
Was $99.99
Men's Franco Chain Gift Set Stainless SteelOnline Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$62.99
Was $89.99
Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Ring 1/20 ct tw Diamonds (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Starting at
$146.16
Mother's Family Birthstone Ring (1-3 Stones and 2-3 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Starting at
$119.55
Couple's Birthstone Double Heart Necklace 1/20 ct tw Diamonds (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Starting at
$177.42
Now + Forever 6mm Satin Wedding Band Rose Tungsten CarbideGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$164.99
Was $219.99
Crucifix Necklace Lord's Prayer Stainless SteelOnline Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$48.99
Was $69.99
Multi-Diamond Cushion-Shaped Promise Ring 1/20 ct tw Sterling SilverGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$104.99
Was $149.99
Oval-Cut Family & Mother's Birthstone Ring (1-4 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Personalized ORDER BY 1/20/2025
Starting at
$87.45
Cultured Pearl Set Necklace, Bracelet & Earrings Sterling SilverGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$187.49
Was $249.99
Now + Forever Wedding Band Black & Brown Tungsten Carbide 8mmGET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY
$262.49
Was $349.99
Showing 42 of 97 products